login join help ad

October 27, 2008

WHY ARE THERE (STILL) THREE GRADES OF GAS?

I know what the difference is - it's octane rating, the property that rates how well a gas resists pre-ignition, or "knocking". But since the invention of electronic fuel injection, the requirement for higher octane grades has faded to practically nothing. I haven't bought anything but the cheapest regular 87 octane gas I could find for 20 years. With one rare exception: when I had a fully-loaded FunBus on a long trip - the higher octane ran a little cooler, and heat is the mortal enemy of the FunBus..

Is this guy trying to say that it is strictly a marketing ploy by the oil companies? I can't find any requirement for there to be 3 grades, just that, well, there are. Wouldn't it be a lot cheaper for the refineries to make only one grade, or do they just "cut" it, like watering down booze? Doesn't sound right to me.

Before EFI, engines ranged from gutless wonders (our pink 62 Rambler American) to monster big blocks, all naturally aspirated via carburetors. I could see there being a need then. But why now?

Why not simply make one grade of gas and sell octane booster separately - available everywhere - for those who need it? Does anybody out there buy mid-grade or premium gas for everyday driving? Why? I can see for off road vehicles, boats, race cars, etc. But again, why not just use octane boost?

You could then convert the other two nozzles to ethanol/methanol or other blends for flex fuel vehicles. The underground tanks and pipes have to be different, but these systems get dug up all the time in California.

Chief? White Lightning? Doodle? Any input on this?

Posted by: JBD at 07:13 PM | Comments (1) | Add Comment
Post contains 290 words, total size 2 kb.

1

JBD

My understanding on this, is this has to do with primarily with compression ratios as you increase the compression in a engine you need the higher octane to prevent detonation.  fuel injectioin is simply a delivery system.  It is the E in EFI that makes the difference, the onboard computers today can not only adjust the timing, tip in and other factors, but my new mustang supposedly can detect the level of octane and adjust accordingly.  I know for instance when you get above 8.5 to 1 compression in a boat you should run 89 when you are above 9.5 you should go to 91 octane.  At least that is what the owners manual states.  It seems a little far fetched that it is a another fraud perpetrated by the big oil companies. But they are rich fuckers that don't pay taxes

Go Obama

 

Posted by: Pix at Wednesday, October 29 2008 10:24 PM (2yD0p)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
8kb generated in CPU 0.0086, elapsed 0.0429 seconds.
25 queries taking 0.0377 seconds, 30 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.